This historic property in Old Town Key West was originally built in the 1880s and stood as The Carriage Trade Inn until its most recent renovation in 2022. The project, undertaken by The Studios of Key West and M. Stratton Architecture, transitioned the property from a deteriorating relic of the past into a restored and adaptive multifunctional space. This adaptive reuse project celebrates the island’s rich architectural heritage while meeting the needs of The Studios of Key West and other community-focused arts organizations.

Throughout the renovation, significant consideration was given to preserving and restoring key elements, including the original exterior doors and windows, the reclaimed Dade County pine siding, and the large covered gathering space in the rear yard. Within the original footprint of the historic home, the floorplan was reimagined to accommodate four private studio apartments, each with an attached workspace. This design provides artists with dedicated living and creative spaces while aiding in collaboration through shared amenities. A communal catering kitchen and covered outdoor living areas serve as central gathering points, offering opportunities for connection and dialogue among residents and guests, all while maintaining a sense of privacy and seclusion from the bustling downtown environment. The new foundation of the PEAR (Peyton Evans Artist Residency) House supports its role as a contemporary canvas for artists, ensuring its adaptability and relevance for years to come.

As a key venue for The Studios of Key West, the property welcomes nearly 40 artists annually—visual artists, writers, performers, and interdisciplinary creatives—who come to draw inspiration from the island’s rich history, diverse community, and subtropical environment. Rooted in the city’s official motto, “One Human Family,” the space reflects a commitment to inclusivity and collaboration, encouraging artists from all backgrounds to engage deeply with the culture and people of Key West.